The Myrtles Plantation Ghost Story: The Truth Behind Chloe, the 17th Step and “America’s Most Haunted House”

Louisiana's most famous haunted house tells of ten murders and a ghost named Chloe. The records tell a different story. Here's the truth, and how to visit.

The story goes like this. A woman wakes in a downstairs bedroom of an old house in St. Francisville and finds someone standing beside the bed: a Black woman in a long dress and a green turban, holding a lit candlestick, so close the candle gives off a soft glow. The sleeper screams, pulls the covers over her head, reaches out to touch the figure, and it’s gone. That was the account Frances Kermeen Myers gave of a night in 1987 at the Myrtles, the house that sells itself as “one of America’s most haunted homes,” and the woman in the turban has a name every ghost hunter knows: Chloe.

Here is the twist. The records say Chloe probably never lived. The poisoned birthday cake never happened. The house’s famous “ten murders” shrink to one. And the most-told legend in Louisiana ghost lore turns out to have a birthday, a songwriter and a family joke behind it. Tonight we separate the documented history of the Myrtles from the legend, tell you what the legend leaves out about the real people who were enslaved there, and show you how to visit. As always on GoLagniappe, a legend is a legend: nobody here is claiming the house is haunted, or that it isn’t.

At a glance: the Myrtles

  • Where: 7747 U.S. Highway 61, St. Francisville, in West Feliciana Parish, about 25 miles north of Baton Rouge.
  • Built: around 1796 by David Bradford, who called it Laurel Grove. Listed on the National Register of Historic Places on Sept. 6, 1978.
  • The legend: an enslaved woman named Chloe poisons the family with a cake, is hanged, and haunts the house in a green turban; ten murders; a dying man’s footsteps that stop on the 17th stair.
  • The record: no Chloe in the family’s documents, deaths from yellow fever, and one documented murder, on the porch, in 1871.
  • Visit: grounds open seven days a week; day tours, self-guided tours, and evening “mystery” tours seven nights a week. Today it’s also a 20-room inn with a restaurant.
  • Best time: the cooler months, October through March, on an evening tour. Book ahead.

From the Myrtles’ official history and tour pages, the National Park Service’s National Register records, and the research of Troy Taylor and David Wiseheart, checked Nov. 17, 2026.

The white manor house of the Myrtles in St. Francisville, Louisiana, with its long front gallery and ironwork, framed by trees
The manor house at the Myrtles in St. Francisville. Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress (no known restrictions).

The legend, as it’s usually told

In the version told for decades, Chloe was enslaved in the household of Clark Woodruff, who ran the place in the 1820s. She is caught listening at a keyhole, and as punishment one of her ears is cut off; from then on she hides the scar under a green turban. To win her way back into the family’s favor, she bakes a birthday cake laced with oleander, a deadly garden shrub, meaning only to make the family sick so she can nurse them back to health. Instead, Woodruff’s wife and two daughters die. The other enslaved people, afraid of being blamed, hang Chloe and throw her body into the Mississippi.

Around that core grew the rest of the house’s reputation: ten murders in all, a mirror said to hold the spirits of the poisoned family, a little girl who died in 1868 despite a Voodoo healer named Cleo, and the footsteps of a murdered man who staggered up the staircase and died on the 17th step. The stories carried the Myrtles onto national television, with an Unsolved Mysteries segment in 2001 and a 2005 episode of Ghost Hunters.

What the records actually show

The real house begins with a fugitive. David Bradford was a Pennsylvania lawyer caught up in the Whiskey Rebellion, the 1794 frontier uprising against a federal tax on liquor. He fled down the rivers to Bayou Sara, near today’s St. Francisville, then part of Spanish West Florida, bought land, and built a modest house he called Laurel Grove. According to research published by ghost-history author Troy Taylor and researcher David Wiseheart, President John Adams pardoned him in 1799, and he brought his family south.

One of Bradford’s law students, Clark Woodruff (he spelled it Woodrooff early on), married Bradford’s daughter Sarah Mathilda on Nov. 19, 1817. They had three children: Cornelia Gale, James and Mary Octavia. Then disease came. Sarah Mathilda died on July 21, 1823. James died on July 15, 1824, and Cornelia followed that September. The cause was yellow fever, the mosquito-borne disease that swept Louisiana in epidemic after epidemic in those years. Even the Myrtles’ own history timeline now says Sarah Mathilda died “likely due to yellow fever,” and that two of her children died of the same illness the next year. It says nothing about poison.

Line that up against the legend and it falls apart. The mother died a year before her children, not at the same party. The children who died were a son and a daughter, not two daughters. The third child, Mary Octavia, lived to adulthood and married; Woodruff himself died peacefully in 1851. And Chloe? Taylor and Wiseheart searched the Woodruff family’s property records, still on file in St. Francisville, and reported that they list the people the family enslaved but no one named Chloe or Cleo. Skeptical investigator Joe Nickell reached the same conclusion in Skeptical Inquirer in 2003.

Did you know? The Myrtles isn’t the only Louisiana house where the brochure story and the courthouse records disagree. In Natchitoches, a historian’s deed-by-deed research overturned the famous legend of Melrose and Marie Thérèse Coincoin. Read the true story of the Cane River Creoles →

The one real murder: William Winter, 1871

In 1834, Woodruff sold the place to Ruffin Grey Stirling, whose family greatly enlarged the house, added the long front gallery with its cast-iron railings, and renamed it for the crape myrtles growing around it. The Stirlings’ daughter Sarah married William Drew Winter at the Myrtles on June 3, 1852, and after the Civil War the Winters lived there.

On Jan. 26, 1871, Winter was teaching a Sunday school lesson in the gentlemen’s parlor when a rider called out that he had business with him. Winter stepped onto the side gallery and was shot. Taylor and Wiseheart cite a report in the Pointe Coupee Democrat that a man named E.S. Webber was to stand trial, with no outcome ever recorded; another researcher points to a New Orleans Republican report that four men were arrested. Either way, the killing appears never to have been solved. Winter was buried the next day at Grace Church in St. Francisville.

That is the only murder the records support. And the famous ending, where Winter staggers back through the parlors and up the staircase to die on the 17th step in his wife’s arms? According to the same research, he fell on the porch and died there. The footsteps on the stairs belong to the legend, not to the newspaper.

A single lit candle in a glass holder glowing against a dark background
The ghost in the turban is said to carry a candle. Photo: Swetha B Chandran, WordPress.org Photo Directory, CC0. Not taken in Louisiana.
Long strands of moss hanging from the branches of oak trees against a blue sky
Moss-hung oaks like the ones around the Myrtles. Photo: mdburnette, WordPress.org Photo Directory, CC0. Location not stated.

So where did Chloe come from?

This is the best part of the story, because it’s true. After the Stirlings, the house passed in 1889 to Harrison Milton Williams, and his family kept it into the 20th century. According to Lucile Lawrason, a Williams granddaughter quoted in Taylor and Wiseheart’s research, her aunts used to talk and laugh about the ghost of an older woman who wore a green bonnet. She had no name and no backstory. She was a family joke.

In 1953, the house was bought by Marjorie Munson, a widow from Oklahoma, who began restoring it. She heard the local talk about odd happenings, asked around, and in 1956, the Myrtles’ own timeline records, wrote a song inspired by the house’s legends, “Peer Through a Silver Keyhole.” Notice the keyhole: it’s the same detail that later becomes Chloe’s crime. Under owners in the 1970s, Taylor writes, the story grew to include the severed ear and the poisoned cake. In the 1980s, James and Frances Kermeen Myers turned the house into a bed-and-breakfast, and the legend went national, appearing in LIFE magazine in November 1980 and in a stream of ghost books after it. With every retelling the body count climbed, until the house had ten murders, including Union soldiers and a stabbed gambler. Taylor found that burial records list that “gambler,” Lewis Stirling, as dying of yellow fever in 1854, and that no record supports the soldiers.

The famous “Chloe photograph” came in 1992. According to the Myrtles’ legend page, the owner at the time took pictures of the grounds for a fire-insurance policy, and one showed what looks like a figure in the breezeway between two buildings. It’s still sold as a postcard. The Cleo legend has the same problem as Chloe’s: Taylor reports that little Kate Winter, the child in that story, died of typhoid at age three, not after a failed Voodoo healing.

What the legend leaves out

There is a harder truth underneath all this. Laurel Grove was a cotton and indigo plantation worked by enslaved people. Federal census counts show the Woodruff household holding 5 enslaved people in 1820 and 32 by 1830, and Taylor notes that when the Stirlings bought the place, the people Woodruff had bought from his mother-in-law were sold along with the land and buildings. Those were real men, women and children, and most of their names never make it onto a ghost tour.

Historian Tiya Miles makes that point in Tales from the Haunted South (UNC Press, 2015), which devotes a chapter to the Myrtles. Reviewers of the book sum up her argument: the invented Chloe and Cleo are built from old, white-authored stereotypes of Black women, the seductive “Jezebel,” the loyal “Mammy,” the exotic Voodoo priestess, and telling those stories for thrills can crowd out the real history of sexual violence and suffering under slavery. You don’t have to stop enjoying a ghost tour to take that seriously. You can simply know which part is history and which part was written in the 1950s and after.

Did you know? Louisiana’s best-loved monster has a gentler streak than the Myrtles’ ghosts. In the old bayou stories, the rougarou is usually a little white dog, not a wolf, and it almost never kills anyone. Meet the real rougarou →

Is it haunted? The skeptic and the believers

Nobody can settle that, and we won’t try. Troy Taylor, who has spent a career writing about haunted places, thinks the house may well be haunted, just not for the reasons the legend gives, and points out that yellow fever alone left plenty of grief behind. Joe Nickell, the late investigator for Skeptical Inquirer, visited in 1991 while being filmed for a Discovery Channel documentary and went looking for the source of banging noises overnight guests reported. He found a loose shutter and slammed it against a drainpipe. Visitors, meanwhile, keep reporting footsteps, a piano and children’s voices. Go, listen, and decide for yourself.

Black-and-white view of still water with a tree line fading into fog
Fog over still water, the kind of night ghost stories are made for. Photo: annezazu, WordPress.org Photo Directory, CC0. Not taken in Louisiana.

Go see it yourself

  • The Myrtles, St. Francisville. 7747 U.S. Highway 61; (225) 635-6277. The grounds are open to the public seven days a week, and there’s a free self-guided walking tour of the grounds (with a phone version). Leashed dogs are welcome outside. Check in for tours at the gift shop next to the main house. themyrtles.com
  • Which tour: guided day tours cover the six downstairs rooms of the main house and lean toward history. Evening Mystery Tours run seven nights a week, with several times on weekends, and focus on the folklore. Private evening tours run Sunday through Thursday at 8 p.m., and there are self-guided house tours and a Garden & Grounds tour of the farm. Times and prices are posted on the booking calendar.
  • Book the evening tour ahead. The operator warns evening tours often sell out, and latecomers may not be able to join or switch.
  • Stay the night or eat there. The property now has 20 guest rooms, Restaurant 1796 and Elta Coffee. Check the official site for current hours.
  • Best time to go: October through March, when evenings are cool and the moss-hung grounds feel right for the stories. October is busiest; a weeknight in winter is quieter.
  • For the history the ghost tours skip: Whitney Plantation in Wallace, on the River Road between Baton Rouge and New Orleans, is a museum dedicated to the history of slavery. Open 9:30 a.m. to 4:30 p.m., last entry 3 p.m., closed Tuesdays. whitneyplantation.org
  • Visit respectfully: the Myrtles was a place of enslavement before it was an attraction, so keep that in mind on the tour. William Winter is buried at Grace Church, an active Episcopal parish in St. Francisville; if you visit the churchyard, be quiet, stay on the paths, don’t touch or rub headstones, and don’t go during services.

Tour types, address and hours were checked on official sites on Nov. 17, 2026, and can change. Confirm before you drive.

Lagniappe: secrets most folks don’t know

  • The ghost got a song before it got a story. Owner Marjorie Munson wrote “Peer Through a Silver Keyhole” in 1956, inspired by the house’s legends, according to the Myrtles’ own timeline. The keyhole later became Chloe’s crime.
  • The original ghost was an older woman in a green bonnet, with no name. A Williams granddaughter recalled her aunts laughing about her. The young, wronged Chloe came later.
  • Ten murders? One. William Winter, shot on the gallery on Jan. 26, 1871, is the only killing the records support, and he died on the porch, not on the 17th step.
  • The house’s own history page doesn’t mention poison. The Myrtles’ official timeline says Sarah Mathilda Woodruff most likely died of yellow fever, and her two children of the same illness the next year.
  • Sources can’t agree how long the gallery is. Taylor’s research gives the Stirlings’ front gallery as 107 feet; the Myrtles’ longtime website calls it a 125-foot verandah. Bring a tape measure and settle it.
  • You don’t need a ticket to see the grounds. The grounds are open daily, and the self-guided walking tour of them is free. Save your ticket money for the evening tour.

Now it’s your turn. Have you taken the evening tour at the Myrtles or stayed the night? Did you hear the footsteps, or just a loose shutter? Did your family tell a different version of the Chloe story? Tell us in the comments. If you’ve got photos from St. Francisville, share them in our Family Album, and if you make the trip, tell us how it went. Find West Feliciana Parish on our Louisiana map, and plan the rest of your season with the Louisiana Festival Calendar.

Sources & further reading

Checked Nov. 17, 2026. Ghost stories are presented here as legends, and the history as the records show it.

Leave a Reply