The Best Fluffy Pancakes recipe you will fall in love with. Full of tips and tricks to help you make the best pancakes.
Every year on All Saints’ night, a candlelight procession winds from St. Augustine Catholic Church to its cemetery on Isle Brevelle, and families set candles on the graves of their Creole ancestors along the Cane River. The woman most of them descend from is not there. The historian who has spent five decades on her trail places her in a long-abandoned cemetery a few miles downriver, in a grave nobody has marked.
Her name was Marie Thérèse, and people called her Coincoin. She was born enslaved in Natchitoches, Louisiana’s oldest town, and her children built one of the most remarkable communities in the American South: a world of free Creoles of color who owned plantations, built their own church and held on to their land for two centuries. Her story is also wrapped in one of Louisiana’s most stubborn tourist myths. Here is the history of Natchitoches and the Cane River Creoles, what the records actually say, and where to see it yourself.

At a glance: Natchitoches and the Cane River Creoles
- Natchitoches (say it NACK-uh-tish): founded in 1714 by Louis Juchereau de St. Denis, the oldest European settlement in present-day Louisiana and the oldest permanent settlement in the Louisiana Purchase.
- Cane River Creoles: a community of Creoles of color centered on Isle Brevelle, about 18,000 acres between the Cane River and Bayou Brevelle. Many descend from Marie Thérèse Coincoin (1742–about 1817) and Claude Thomas Pierre Metoyer.
- Cane River Lake: about 36 miles long. It was the main channel of the Red River until the river changed course in the 1830s.
- Where to go: Cane River Creole National Historical Park (Oakland and Magnolia plantations), Melrose, St. Augustine Church and downtown Natchitoches.
From 64 Parishes, the National Park Service, Northwestern State University’s Louisiana Regional Folklife Program and Elizabeth Shown Mills’s research in Louisiana History, checked Nov. 14, 2026.
1714: a trading post on the Red River
Natchitoches was born from a trade deal that was technically against the law. The governor of French Louisiana, Antoine de la Mothe Cadillac, wanted a back door into Spanish Texas, where direct trade with the French was forbidden. He sent Louis Juchereau de St. Denis, a French Canadian who had sailed with Iberville and Bienville in 1699 and knew the Red River tribes well. St. Denis brought the Natchitoches people back to their old home on the Red River, persuaded them to share it with the Doustioni already living there, and with their help built Fort St. Jean Baptiste des Natchitoches on an island in the river, according to 64 Parishes.
Spain answered by building a mission at the Adaes village, just fifteen miles west. The Spanish jailed St. Denis for a time; he came home, bought 60,000 livres’ worth of trade goods and went right on trading. It was a tiny place: in 1722 the civilian population was 34 people, with 20 enslaved. St. Denis ran the post until 1744 and died that year. The town kept the name of the Natchitoches people who had made it possible.

The river that walked away
For more than a century Natchitoches sat at the head of navigation, just below the Great Raft, a logjam that choked well over a hundred miles of the Red River. In the 1830s steamboat captain Henry Miller Shreve cleared it, and the river took its revenge: it cut a new channel near Grand Ecore, north of town, and left Natchitoches on a backwater. Country Roads magazine notes that Shreve and his partners founded a new port upstream, incorporated in 1836 as Shreveport.
The old channel became Cane River Lake, later dammed into the long, still ribbon that runs through downtown and down past the Creole plantations. Because the river walked away, the steamboat money went elsewhere, and much of old Natchitoches simply stayed put. The National Park Service puts it plainly: the town’s greatest industry has been preserving its own past.

Did you know? That quiet oxbow is now the stage for one of the biggest light shows in the South. The lights along Cane River Lake come on for the season at Turn on the Holidays on Saturday, Nov. 21, 2026, in the festival’s 100th season. Everything you need for the trip: The Natchitoches Christmas Festival of Lights guide →
Coincoin: born enslaved in 1742
In August 1742 an enslaved African couple owned by the commandant, St. Denis, had a daughter. The historian and genealogist Elizabeth Shown Mills, who has studied her since 1972, calculates that the baby was the forty-sixth person St. Denis held in slavery. She was baptized Marie Thérèse; her family called her Coincoin. At sixteen she lost both parents and her widowed mistress to an epidemic. Between 1759 and 1766 she bore five children in a slave union.
Her owners then rented her out to a newly arrived French merchant, Claude Thomas Pierre Metoyer, to keep his house and tavern. The arrangement became a relationship that lasted about twenty years and produced ten children. In 1777 a crusading Spanish priest brought criminal charges over it. Under the local slave ordinance, Mills writes, an enslaved woman convicted of such “libertinage” faced public shaming on the “wooden horse” and a hundred lashes, and Louisiana’s Code Noir allowed her and her children to be seized and sold in New Orleans. To protect her, Metoyer bought her and privately freed her.
In the late 1780s Metoyer ended the relationship to marry a local widow, also named Marie Thérèse. He left Coincoin about 68 acres beside his plantation on the Côte Joyeuse, the “Joyous Coast” below town, and a small yearly allowance. What she did next made her a legend. She planted tobacco, trapped bears and wild turkeys and sold bear oil and pelts; in 1792 she and Metoyer sent a flatboat and a bateau loaded with skins, oil and tobacco down to New Orleans. In 1794 she won a Spanish grant of 800 arpents of piney woods on Old River and ran cattle there. With her earnings she bought the freedom of children and grandchildren scattered from Opelousas to Nacogdoches.
Her story has a hard edge, and the historians who admire her most don’t hide it. Coincoin also bought enslaved Africans to work her land, and Mills calls her life a paradox: slave, slave owner and mother at once. When she died, many of her own offspring were still enslaved.
The legend of Melrose, and the man who invented it
If you’ve read a brochure about the Cane River, you’ve probably met a different Coincoin: a Congo-born slave girl who was freed, cleared the forest, grew indigo and built Melrose Plantation in the 1740s or 1750s, African House and all. It is a wonderful story. According to Mills’s prize-winning 2012 article in Louisiana History, almost none of it is true.
She traced the legend to one man. François Mignon arrived at Melrose in the early 1940s for a six-week visit and stayed 32 years as its resident writer and historian. He said he was from Paris; Melrose’s own history page now says he was Frank Mineah of Cortland, New York. Mills found that the accounts written before Mignon, starting in 1927, credited Melrose to a man, Louis Metoyer. Mignon, legally blind and a storyteller rather than a researcher, gave the plantation a heroic founding mother, and pushed her building dates back to 1750 and later to 1743. The indigo was his touch too; the records show her growing tobacco.
The real founder was her son. In 1796 Louis Metoyer received a 911-acre concession on Isle Brevelle, though he was still legally enslaved; his father didn’t formally free him until 1802. He then fought a prominent white claimant in court for twelve years and won in 1818. Melrose’s own history dates Yucca House, African House and the big barn to between 1810 and 1815, the government’s architectural survey dates African House to about 1820, and Mills argues the serious building came after the 1818 court win. Louis began the big house in 1832, died that March, and his son finished it.
The myth wouldn’t die, partly because people loved it. After the first historical study in 1972, one of Coincoin’s descendants wrote to Mills that she still told visitors Coincoin built Melrose, “because I want them to be proud of her.” In 1978 a son of Melrose’s last private owners declared an old bousillage cabin on Coincoin’s farmstead her true home, and that cabin, now called the Coincoin-Prudhomme House, became the next legend. The government’s architectural survey dates it to 1828–1847, after her death, and a 2016 archaeological review concluded it was probably an overseer’s house on the later Prudhomme plantation.

Where Coincoin really spent her last years
For years the official story said Coincoin sold her farm in March 1816 and died later that year. In a later Louisiana History article, “Laying a Legend to Rest,” Mills showed that the courthouse clerk had copied one deed into the wrong year. The numbered packets of the original records show the farm was really sold in early 1813, and Coincoin had likely moved downriver as early as 1807.
Tracing her witnesses and every land title along the river, Mills places her last home just below Isle Brevelle at Rivière aux Cannes, where archaeologists have found pottery and nails from her lifetime. A family elder told the Millses in the 1970s that her son Augustin moved her downriver so the family could care for her. No record marks her death, but in mid-March 1817 her sons suddenly gathered there and reshuffled the family’s land and money as they did at no other time in their lives. Mills concludes she died then and was buried in the now-abandoned Rivière aux Cannes cemetery known as Shallow Lake.
Isle Brevelle: the free Creoles of color
Coincoin didn’t build the empire, but her children did. Her eldest Metoyer son, Nicolas Augustin, received land on Isle Brevelle in the 1790s, and his brothers followed. By the 1830s, Mills calculates, her offspring owned some 18,000 acres on the Isle and held nearly 500 people in slavery. They were planters, churchmen and patrons of the arts, in a parish where most people of African descent were enslaved. It is uncomfortable history, and it is Louisiana history: French and Spanish law had given free people of color a chance to prosper that the American regime steadily took away.
Augustin, remembered on the river as Grandpère Augustin, kept the family out of debt and moved relatives across the family lands “like pawns on a chessboard,” in Mills’s words. His great project was a church. Northwestern State University’s folklife program dates the first chapel to 1803 and the blessing of the first church building to 1829, and calls St. Augustine the first Catholic church in America founded, financed and built by free people of color. The present church dates to 1916 or 1917, depending on the source, and Augustin’s 1836 portrait by J. Feuille still hangs inside.
The good years ended fast. Louis’s grandson Théophile inherited Melrose as a teenager, fell deep into debt, and in 1847 lost it at auction to the Hertzog brothers for $8,340. The Civil War, the Red River Campaign of 1864 and Reconstruction finished off most of the Creole fortunes. The land, though, largely stayed. NSU’s folklife program reports that about 16,000 of the Isle’s 18,000 acres are still owned by descendants of the original Creole families.
Did you know? “Creole” doesn’t mean the same thing everywhere in Louisiana. On the Cane River it names a community of mixed French, Spanish, African and Native American ancestry; in New Orleans it once meant the colonial-born French and Spanish elite. The Cajuns came later, from Nova Scotia. Untangle it with our story of how the Acadians became Cajuns →
Across the river: Oakland and Magnolia
White French Creole planters lined the same river, and two of their plantations now form Cane River Creole National Historical Park, where the National Park Service tells the story through the people who did the work. At Oakland, Emmanuel Prud’homme began farming in 1785 and received a Spanish grant in 1789. Family tradition says the Prud’hommes were the first west of the Mississippi to grow cotton on a large scale. By the Civil War nearly 160 enslaved people labored there. Enslaved workers built the main house in 1821, and it stayed a Prud’homme family home until 1998.

Downriver at Magnolia, the LeComte family became the parish’s biggest cotton producers and its largest slaveholders: 235 people in 1860, according to park records. Enslaved workers built two-room brick cabins there beginning as early as 1845, each first housing two families. Eight survive. After emancipation they became tenant houses, and one was lived in into the 1970s. The NPS calls them the only brick quarters for enslaved people in Louisiana. Union soldiers burned Magnolia’s main house in 1864; the gin barn survived, and its wooden screw press is, the park says, the last of its kind in the United States still on its original site.


Melrose’s second life: Cammie Henry and Clementine Hunter
In 1884 Melrose passed to Joseph Henry, who named it for Sir Walter Scott’s poem about Melrose Abbey. His daughter-in-law, Cammie Garrett Henry, restored the old buildings and, after her husband died in 1918, made Melrose a retreat for artists and writers. Lyle Saxon wrote most of his Cane River novel Children of Strangers there, and Melrose lists William Faulkner, Rachel Field and Ada Jack Carver among her guests.
The most important artist at Melrose wasn’t a guest. Clementine Hunter, born in 1887 at nearby Hidden Hill Plantation, started picking cotton at Melrose at about twelve and later became its cook. She began painting with paints a visiting artist left behind, and never learned to read or write. In 1955, at 68, she finished her most famous work: murals in oil on plywood for the upstairs of African House. In the 1960s Northwestern State University wouldn’t let her onto campus to see an exhibit of her own work because of segregation; in 1986 it gave her an honorary doctorate. She died in 1988 at 101. When Melrose’s contents were auctioned in 1970, her murals were torn from every building except African House, which is why you can still see them there.

Go see it yourself
- Cane River Creole National Historical Park, Oakland and Magnolia units. Grounds and outbuildings are open for self-guided tours Wednesday through Sunday, 9:30 a.m. to 3:30 p.m.; the Oakland main house opens Saturdays and Sundays, 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. Guided tours are by appointment. Closed Mondays, Tuesdays and federal holidays. Check nps.gov/cari for alerts and road conditions before you drive.
- Melrose, 3533 La. 119, Melrose. Run by the Association for the Preservation of Historic Natchitoches; guided tours Thursday through Sunday, 10 a.m. to 5 p.m., per melroseonthecane.com. African House and the Hunter murals are the reason to go.
- St. Augustine Catholic Church, 2262 La. 484, Natchez. An active parish, not a museum. The respectful way to see it is to attend Mass; walk the cemetery quietly and never touch graves or offerings.
- Downtown Natchitoches. Front Street and the riverbank, then the Cane River drive south on La. 119 and La. 494. Find every stop on our Cajun Country & Louisiana map.
- Best time to go: late fall and early winter, when the heat breaks and, from Nov. 21, the Christmas lights are on along Cane River Lake. Pair a weekend day at the park, when the Oakland house is open, with an evening downtown.
- Be a good guest: most of Isle Brevelle is private land owned by Creole families. Stay on the highways and public sites, and don’t walk up to homes or into family cemeteries uninvited.
Hours checked Nov. 14, 2026, from the NPS (page updated April 2026) and Melrose’s website. They change; check before you go.
Lagniappe: secrets most folks don’t know
- The Library of Congress still repeats the myth. The catalog record for the government’s own survey of Melrose says Coincoin established it and calls Louis Metoyer her grandson. He was her son, and he founded it.
- Melrose’s founder held his land while enslaved. Louis Metoyer got his 911-acre concession in 1796, six years before his father legally freed him.
- The famous “Coincoin house” was built after she died. The federal architectural survey dates the Coincoin-Prudhomme House to 1828–1847; archaeologists now think it was an overseer’s house.
- A clerk’s slip moved her history by three years. Her farm sale was copied into the 1816 deed book, but the numbered originals show it happened in 1813.
- Melrose’s storyteller wasn’t French. “François Mignon” of Paris was Frank Mineah of Cortland, New York, and the 1740s founding dates came from him.
- Clementine Hunter’s murals survived by luck. At the 1970 auction, her paintings were torn out of every Melrose building except African House.
- Say it right: the old name for the riverbank south of town is Côte Joyeuse, the Joyous Coast, and bousillage (boo-see-YAHZH) is the mud-and-moss wall fill of old Creole houses. More Louisiana French on our Speak Cajun page.
Keep Going Down the Bayou
- Natchitoches Christmas Festival: The Complete Guide: the schedule, the fireworks and the 100th season on Cane River Lake.
- The Acadian Exile: the other great migration story of French Louisiana.
- The Great Flood of 1927: what happens when Louisiana’s rivers decide to move, one more time.
- Cajun & Zydeco Music: A Listener’s Guide: zydeco is Creole music, born in the same mixed French-and-African world.
- The Rougarou: another Louisiana legend where the records tell a better story than the brochure.
- If you liked this, you’ll love: Papa Noël and Louisiana’s Christmas legends, including the alligator team that started as a car ad. Then browse Louisiana A to Z.
Now it’s your turn. Does your family come from the Cane River, Isle Brevelle or Natchitoches? Do you remember Melrose, the St. Augustine church fair or the All Saints’ candles? Tell us in the comments. We’d love to see old family photos in our Family Album, and if you drive the Cane River this season, tell us how the trip went. Planning a holiday visit? Start at our Louisiana Holiday Season hub.
Sources & further reading
- Elizabeth Shown Mills, “Demythicizing History: Marie Thérèse Coincoin, Tourism, and the National Historical Landmarks Program,” Louisiana History 53 (Fall 2012), and “Laying a Legend to Rest: Marie Thérèse Coincoin and Archaeological Sites 16NA785 and 16NA789,” Louisiana History
- 64 Parishes: Laura D. Kelley, “Natchitoches Settlement”; “Clementine Hunter”; “Cammie Garrett Henry”
- National Park Service, Cane River Creole NHP: Plan Your Visit, Oakland Plantation, Magnolia Plantation, African American History; Cane River National Heritage Area history
- Northwestern State University, Louisiana Regional Folklife Program: Cane River Creole Community, St. Augustine Catholic Church, 200th Anniversary and All Saints Day
- Association for the Preservation of Historic Natchitoches, Melrose history; Country Roads, “The Great River Raft”
- Photographs: Library of Congress, Historic American Buildings Survey (African House, Magnolia quarters, Magnolia cotton press, Melrose, Oakland, Natchitoches riverfront) and FSA/OWI (Marion Post Wolcott, Melrose store, 1940)
- Further reading: Gary B. Mills and Elizabeth Shown Mills, The Forgotten People: Cane River’s Creoles of Color (rev. ed., LSU Press, 2013); Lyle Saxon, Children of Strangers (1937)
Checked Nov. 14, 2026. Where sources disagree on a date, we give both.



[…] See also: Louisiana’s other French-speaking story began 40 years before the Acadians arrived, on the Red River at Natchitoches. Meet the free Creoles of color of Isle Brevelle in Natchitoches and the Cane River Creoles. […]
[…] See also: who really built Melrose, and why the famous “Coincoin” story isn’t what the records say. Read Natchitoches and the Cane River Creoles: the true story. […]
[…] Did you know? Natchitoches is older than New Orleans, and the Creole families of the Cane River country shaped it long before the lights went up. Here’s the true story of Marie Thérèse Coincoin, Melrose and Louisiana’s oldest town. Read Natchitoches and the Cane River Creoles → […]