King Cake: The True History of Louisiana’s Carnival Cake, the Plastic Baby and the Rules Locals Live By

A gold bean that crowned a queen, a salesman's leftover dolls, a rain curse: the true history of Louisiana king cake and the rules locals still live by.

On Twelfth Night in 1871, a young New Orleans debutante named Emma Butler cut into a slice of cake at a masked ball and found a bean made of gold. By the rules of the evening, that little bean made her queen of Carnival.

Today the bean is a plastic baby, the cake is a braided ring of cinnamon dough under a snowfall of purple, green and gold sugar, and the reward for finding the prize is no crown at all. It’s an obligation: you bring the next one. Between Twelfth Night and Fat Tuesday, Louisiana goes through king cakes by the hundreds of thousands, and nearly everything people “know” about them, from what the baby means to how it got there, turns out to be a better story than the one usually told. This is Part 5 of our Mardi Gras series and part of our Louisiana Holiday Season guide. If you’re new to the series, start with Part 1: the history of Mardi Gras.

At a glance: king cake season 2027

  • Season opens: Wednesday, Jan. 6, 2027, Twelfth Night (the Feast of the Epiphany).
  • Season ends: Fat Tuesday, Feb. 9, 2027. A short Carnival, so plan your king cake parties early.
  • The rule: whoever gets the slice with the baby brings the next king cake.
  • The curse: legend says eating king cake out of season brings rain on Mardi Gras Day.
  • How many: more than 500,000 sold in greater New Orleans each Carnival, plus about 50,000 shipped out of state, by the tourism bureau’s count.
  • Main styles: New Orleans brioche or Danish ring, French galette des rois, Acadiana’s fried doughnut cake, and the savory boudin king cake.

2027 dates from New Orleans & Company’s official Mardi Gras date table. Sales figures cited by 64 Parishes. Bakery seasons and shipping change every year; check each bakery’s own site before you go.

Freshly baked cinnamon rolls with white icing on a cooling rack
The classic New Orleans king cake is, at heart, a giant braided cinnamon roll: sweet yeast dough, cinnamon swirl, white icing. Add a braid, a ring shape, Carnival sugar and a hidden baby. (These are plain cinnamon rolls, not a Louisiana photo. Jackson Monichan, WordPress.org Photo Directory, CC0.)

What a king cake is, and why it’s named for kings

In its most common Louisiana form, a king cake is a round or oval ring of braided, sweet cinnamon pastry, iced and sprinkled in Carnival colors. The “king” is not Rex. It’s the three kings, the Magi, whose visit to the infant Jesus the Catholic calendar celebrates on Jan. 6, the Epiphany, also called Twelfth Night because it falls twelve days after Christmas. That same date opens the Carnival season, which runs to Mardi Gras.

As Rien Fertel explains in the 64 Parishes encyclopedia, Catholic Europe marked Epiphany with a special cake, and every country had its own: the galette des rois in France, Dreikönigskuchen in German-speaking lands, roscón de reyes in Spain and Twelfth Cake in Britain. Each hid a small prize, a bean, a coin, a charm or a tiny porcelain figure, and whoever got it became “king” for the day. The French name that came to Louisiana was gâteau des rois, the cake of kings. (Collect more of the old words on our Speak Cajun page.)

The Southern Food and Beverage Museum, which built an oral-history exhibit around king cake, is careful to say the exact origins of the New Orleans version are debated and uncertain. The city’s cake was likely shaped by everyone who lived here: French and Spanish colonists, Anglo-Americans, Irish and German immigrants, and enslaved Africans. What’s documented is when it turns up on the record, and the first big appearance is a ball.

1871: the gold bean that crowned a queen

The Twelfth Night Revelers, one of New Orleans’ oldest Carnival societies, formed in 1870 and paraded on Jan. 6 to the French Opera House to choose their royalty. Some krewes voted for their kings and queens; the Revelers left it to chance, and the chance was a cake. 64 Parishes dates the famous ball to 1871: a cake held one bean of gold and several of silver, and Emma Butler, who drew the gold, became what Fertel calls Mardi Gras’s first queen. (Some histories put the first gold bean at the 1870 ball. The records agree on everything but the year.)

That night started a king cake boom. Bakeries began specializing in French-style Twelfth Night cakes, and, in Fertel’s words, Twelfth Night parties could no longer go ahead without one. The Revelers still choose their queen with beans, but the New Orleans bean company Camellia Brand, which has researched the custom, says the cake is now a wooden replica: debutantes pull open little drawers in its lower layer, and the one who finds the single gold bean among the sterling silver ones is queen. Silver makes you a member of the court.

A colorful Rex parade float rolling through New Orleans during Mardi Gras
Carnival royalty still rides in New Orleans. A Rex parade float; the Twelfth Night Revelers, who crowned their first queen by cake, open the ball season every Jan. 6.

From one night to a whole season (and the years doughnuts ruled)

King cake was already a store-bought treat in the 1890s. The museum’s exhibit quotes the 1899 diary of a New Orleanian, Alice Berthelot Gendron, who came home from shopping with an armful of packages, one of them a king cake her aunt nearly ruined by dropping the bag. For decades it stayed a Twelfth Night cake. Then two things happened.

First, the shape settled. By the 1930s, 64 Parishes says, the king cake had become the round, braided ring we know. Second, it went mass-market. Department stores and grocery stores sold cheaper, sweeter, factory-made king cakes decorated in purple, green and gold, the colors Rex had chosen back in 1872, and the cake spread from one night to the whole Carnival season. Even so, it took a while to conquer the big day itself. In the 1920s and 1930s, according to the museum, the journal of the New Orleans Master Bakers’ Association announced that on Mardi Gras, the doughnut was king. Until the 1950s, locals and visitors ate doughnuts, not king cake, on Fat Tuesday.

Cafe du Monde coffee stand in the French Quarter, New Orleans
Café du Monde in the French Quarter, home of the beignet. New Orleans has always loved fried dough: in the 1920s and 1930s the Master Bakers’ journal declared the doughnut “king” of Mardi Gras day.

Did you know? King cake isn’t the only New Orleans sweet whose “French” origin story falls apart in the records. Historians reject the popular tale that pralines came over with the Ursuline nuns, too. Read the true story of the pralinières →

How a baby got into the cake

For most of its history the prize was a bean, the fève, or a pecan. Once in a while in the early 1900s, the museum notes, a baker tucked in a tiny porcelain doll called a Frozen Charlotte. The doll took its name from a famous poem first published in Maine in 1843 about a girl so proud of her dress that she refused to wear a coat, and froze to death on her sleigh ride to a New Year’s ball. A cheerful thing to find in your dessert.

The baby as we know it came from one bakery: McKenzie’s, the big New Orleans chain that dominated king cake until it closed in 2000. Its owner, Donald Entringer Sr., told the story more or less the same way for decades. A salesman with a supply of little china dolls he couldn’t sell suggested Entringer put them in his cakes, and pointed out that a doll wouldn’t get lost like a bean. The museum’s exhibit says Entringer recalled using the china dolls since the late 1930s; many other accounts place it in the 1940s. Either way, most bakeries switched to cheaper plastic babies after World War II, and by the 1960s, 64 Parishes says, the plastic baby was the norm, right alongside the plastic beads thrown from the floats.

So is the baby the Christ child? Entringer himself said no. “It was just a trinket that happened to be a baby,” he told Camellia Brand’s interviewer. Liz Williams, founder of the Southern Food and Beverage Museum, has traced the drift for Garden & Gun: McKenzie’s porcelain dolls made its cake the one everybody wanted, people called the prizes “baby dolls,” then just “the baby,” and because the cake was tied to the Epiphany, the baby slowly became baby Jesus in the popular mind. The museum adds that the idea may also have been shaped by the Latin American rosca de reyes, where the figure does represent Jesus, and whoever finds it hosts a party on Candlemas, Feb. 2.

The baby kept evolving. In the mid-1980s, according to the museum, bakeries began adding brown babies to reflect the city they serve, and today you’ll find them in purple, green and gold, too. And at least one bakery brought porcelain back. Haydel’s Bakery hired the ceramic artist Alberta Lewis to design a new collectible figure every year, and the series has included Mardi Gras Indians, a Rex float and, after Hurricane Katrina, a tiny porcelain FEMA trailer decorated for Mardi Gras.

Myth vs. the record

  • Myth: the baby has always stood for baby Jesus. Record: the man who first put babies in New Orleans king cakes said it was simply a cute trinket. The religious meaning grew up around it later.
  • Myth: king cake has always been purple, green and gold. Record: the Carnival colors date to Rex in 1872 and spread to king cakes with the mass-market cakes of the 20th century.
  • Myth: “you bring the next cake” is an ancient rule. Record: the old custom was that the bean-finder threw the next king cake party, often a week later. Bringing the next cake to the office is the modern version.
  • Myth: some people swallow the baby to get out of paying. Record: it’s a joke left over from the bean days. A 1965 article in the Times-Picayune‘s Dixie magazine said boys who didn’t want to host the party would simply swallow the pecan. Never try it with plastic.
  • Myth: king cake was always eaten on Mardi Gras day. Record: until the 1950s, Fat Tuesday belonged to the doughnut.

The rules locals live by

Not before Jan. 6, not after Fat Tuesday. Bakeries and grocery stores keep trying to sell Halloween, Christmas and Saints king cakes, and some bakeries ship all year for visitors who want a taste of Carnival. But many New Orleanians, as 64 Parishes and the museum’s interviews both report, refuse to eat king cake outside the season. The legend says it brings rain on Mardi Gras Day. (Christmas tables in Louisiana keep plenty of other sweets; see what Louisiana eats at Christmas, and what it leaves off.)

Get the baby, bring the next cake. That’s the rule in every office, school and family in south Louisiana. Linh Tran Garza of Dong Phuong Bakery has described how, in New Orleans schools, somebody brings a king cake nearly every Friday leading up to Mardi Gras, and when it was your turn, you wanted to bring a good one. Getting the baby is good luck, and it’s also a bill.

Buy it; don’t bake it. Gumbo, jambalaya and red beans are home cooking. King cake mostly isn’t. Bakers and customers told the museum that New Orleans heat and humidity make yeast dough unpredictable and the process is long, so most families buy theirs, a habit that goes back at least to that 1899 diary. If you do want to bake one, our Louisiana recipes are the place to start.

Round balls of floured dough on a floured board with a rolling pin
Yeast dough takes time, and Louisiana humidity makes it fickle, two reasons most king cakes come from a bakery box. (Not a Louisiana photo. Tawhid Sadman, WordPress.org Photo Directory, CC0.)

Safety: mind the baby

  • A plastic baby is a choking hazard. Tell everyone, especially children, that there’s a baby in the cake before you cut it.
  • Many bakeries now pack the baby separately, on top or in the box, and leave the hiding to you. Haydel’s Bakery is one that still puts it inside; David Haydel has said you can find it by running your hand under the cake.
  • Baking at home? Never bake the plastic baby. The LSU AgCenter’s king cake recipe says to place the baby under the cake once it has cooled.

New Orleans vs. Cajun Country: the styles

Ask for “a king cake” in New Orleans and in Lafayette and you may walk out with two very different things. Here’s the lay of the land.

StyleWhat it isWell-loved names (check seasons)
Classic Louisiana ringBraided brioche or Danish dough with cinnamon, often filled (cream cheese, praline, strawberry), iced and sugared.Haydel’s Bakery, New Orleans area; Gambino’s; Keller’s Bakery, Lafayette
Laminated briocheButtery, croissant-style layered dough with a cream cheese icing; flakier and lighter.Dong Phuong Bakery, New Orleans East
Galette des roisThe French original: puff pastry filled with almond cream, a hidden fève and a paper crown.Poupart’s Bakery, Lafayette; La Boulangerie, New Orleans
Doughnut king cakeDoughnut dough braided and fried instead of baked, then iced and sugared.Meche’s, Lafayette; Southern Maid, Shreveport; several New Orleans doughnut shops
Boudin king cakeSavory: sweet dough stuffed with boudin, often topped with cane syrup and cracklin.Twin’s Burgers & Sweets, Lafayette
Sources: KPEL News (Jan. 2026), Lafayette Travel, Télé-Louisiane, Garden & Gun, Southern Foodways Alliance. Names are local favorites from those reports, not our own taste test.

The French original came to Lafayette with a Frenchman. François Poupart emigrated from France and opened Poupart’s Bakery in Lafayette in 1967, Lafayette Travel reports; the family introduced the city to the true French king cake, puff pastry and almond with a paper crown, back when modern king cakes were still mostly a New Orleans thing. Poupart’s bakes the Louisiana ring, too.

Acadiana’s own twists. Keller’s Bakery, Télé-Louisiane notes, builds its king cakes on a Danish pastry recipe more than 120 years old, from a family that baked in France before coming to south Louisiana. Meche’s made the fried, doughnut-dough king cake an Acadiana hallmark. And around 2014 or 2015, depending on the account, University of Louisiana at Lafayette historian Robert Carriker topped a boudin-stuffed bread with cane syrup and cracklin, posted it online, and was buried in orders; he teamed up with Twin’s Burgers & Sweets to fill them, and the boudin king cake was born.

Did you know? The man behind the boudin king cake is the same Robert Carriker whose research maps the Southern Boudin Trail, and the rice in your boudin only arrived after large-scale rice farming came to the prairie in the late 1800s. Get the boudin story and recipe →

How king cake went nationwide

For most of the 20th century you had to be in south Louisiana to get one. That changed in the mid-1980s, and the museum’s exhibit gives two reasons. In 1985 the oil bust sent thousands of Louisianians away to look for work, and they wanted their Carnival traditions wherever they landed. In 1986, Federal Express partnered with New Orleans bakeries including Gambino’s and Haydel’s to ship king cakes nationwide, often with beads and doubloons in the box. Twenty years later, Hurricane Katrina scattered New Orleanians across the country, and king cake sales outside Louisiana climbed again as displaced families kept Carnival in new cities and shared the cake with their neighbors.

Haydel’s Bakery has been open since 1959 and bakes more than 75,000 king cakes a year, according to 64 Parishes; third-generation baker David Haydel has said the bakery starts preparing for the season in early November and was among the first to ship king cakes across the country. Dong Phuong Bakery tells a newer Louisiana story. Huong and De Tran, who came to New Orleans East as refugees after the Vietnam War, took over the bakery in 1982, the Southern Foodways Alliance records. Known first for French bread and Vietnamese pastry, it won a James Beard America’s Classics award in 2018, and its laminated brioche king cake, which the SFA calls the most sought-after cake in all of New Orleans, has made a corner of New Orleans East a Carnival destination. The bakery’s name means “the east.”

Listen to the bakers

The Southern Food and Beverage Museum’s free online exhibit “The History and Evolution of King Cakes” lets you hear the voices behind this story: Mardi Gras guide publisher Arthur Hardy on the Twelfth Night Revelers, David Haydel Jr. on the brown king cake baby, Bywater Bakery on the gold baby, Angelo Brocato’s on the season, and Linh Garza of Dong Phuong on why king cake belongs to New Orleans.

Lagniappe: secrets most folks don’t know

  • The Twelfth Night queen still draws a bean, from a drawer. The Revelers now use a wooden replica cake with little drawers in its bottom layer: sterling silver beans for the court, one gold bean for the queen.
  • Fat Tuesday used to be doughnut day. Until the 1950s, New Orleanians ate doughnuts, not king cake, on Mardi Gras. The bakers’ own trade journal called the doughnut king.
  • Before the baby came a frozen girl. The occasional porcelain prize in early-1900s cakes was a Frozen Charlotte, a doll named for an 1843 poem about a girl who froze on the way to a New Year’s ball.
  • Collect the porcelain. Every Haydel’s king cake comes with a handcrafted porcelain collectible, a new design each year. The post-Katrina FEMA trailer is the one collectors talk about.
  • The baby comes in more than one color. New Orleans bakeries began offering brown babies in the mid-1980s, and gold, purple and green ones followed.
  • Got a Mexican or Texan friend? You may owe two parties. In the rosca de reyes tradition, the finder hosts on Candlemas, Feb. 2. In Louisiana, the finder just brings the next cake.
  • Plan ahead in a short season. With Fat Tuesday on Feb. 9, 2027, Carnival is barely five weeks long, so the parties pile up fast. Check your favorite bakery’s site in late December for its season start and shipping cutoffs, and remember that a traditionalist won’t touch a slice before Jan. 6.

Now settle the argument for us: which king cake is your family’s, and did anybody ever “accidentally” swallow the baby? Tell us in the comments. Got a photo of your king cake, or an old Haydel’s porcelain baby? Send it to our Family Album, and we’d love to share it here since there’s no free photo of a real Louisiana king cake to be found. If your family bakes its own, share the recipe. Coming up in the series: the Mardi Gras Indians, throws and krewe culture, Mardi Gras beyond New Orleans and Carnival with kids. Follow along at our Louisiana Holiday Season hub.

Sources & further reading

Leave a Reply